Join our email list

On Shavuot, Reverse the Paucity of Ideas that Threatens Judaism, Israel

In a world where all Jews are Jews by choice we will be sustained only if we field a religion filled with ideas and values that inspire commitment and give meaning to belonging
Rabbi Dr. Donniel Hartman is president of the Shalom Hartman Institute and holds the Kaufman Family Chair in Jewish Philosophy. He is author of the Boundaries of Judaism, and Putting God Second: How to Save Religion from Itself. His latest book, Who are the Jews and Who Can We Become, was a 2023 Jewish Book Council Award Finalist.  Donniel is also the host of the award-winning podcast For Heaven’s Sake, together with his colleague Yossi Klein
Israelis celebrate Shavuot more than any other Jewish community in the world. On erev Shavuot, religious, secular and traditional Jews from all over the country will join in the tens of thousands to study in various and incredibly diverse programs of Tikkun Leil Shavuot. What was once the inheritance of primarily the Orthodox has now become the inheritance of many.
The renaissance of Shavuot has not been accompanied by increased ritual observance. As distinct from Pesah and Succot, Shavuot is not commemorated with an abundance of ritual observances, but rather with a concentration on the act of studying Torah. It symbolizes the idea that we Jews are a people of the book, and that to be a Jew means to be involved in study and thought. Talmud Torah, for some, is important for it can lead to practice. (BT Kiddushin 40b). This is not its meaning in modern Israel, nor do I believe, even amongst the Rabbis. When the Rabbis declare: “The study of Torah surpasses them all,” (Mishnah Peah 1:1), they are not referring to the study required to prefect the practice of Jewish ritual, for that which is needed in order to attain this goal is marginal.
Torah study is significant not merely because it enables practice but rather because it redefines the focus of Judaism’s religious agenda away from observance alone and toward a world of thought and ideas, as well. To celebrate Shavuot is to declare that in our religious tradition, what we think, how we think, and what ideas we produce are critical to the quality and nature of our Jewish identities and lives.
As we celebrate Shavuot this year, we find ourselves in a particularly precarious position, for we are increasingly becoming a people in which the ethos of Torah study – that is, to believe that ideas are important – is being seriously threatened. We have become a people motivated and guided by crises, from Ahmadinejad and Iranian missiles, to Jewish continuity, to Madoff. These crises are treated like fires that must be extinguished; these efforts, however, are quenching much of our creativity.
We have flattened our intellectual horizons and transformed serious issues in need of serious new thinking into shallow debates, the bantering slogans, and short-term solutions. ” United Jerusalem,” a ” two-state solution,” “Peace Now,” Israel as a “Jewish Democratic State,” “Jewish continuity,” have all become slogans bantered about instead of issues that require our deepest and most creative thoughts.
How we build a Jewish and Democratic state with a large Palestinian Arab minority is not an issue to be manipulated for public political points, but one which intellectually and morally we must struggle with. The future of the West Bank and the settlements has been transformed into a question of what U.S. President Obama wants and will let us get away with and not what we want to be in the future. Israel and Jewish morality of war has become an issue debated along political lines, as if it is only a political and not a moral issue.
In the name of Jewish continuity we are engaging in endless studies to learn exactly the Jewish sensibilities, or lack thereof, of our youth. Yet we are rarely using this knowledge to develop a vision of where they ought to be and how we can inspire them to get there, but rather to chase after them in panic under the vague notion that if we reach them wherever they are, they may somehow want to “continue” to be Jews. We have transformed our public discourse into one of slogans instead of substance.
Shavuot and the commandment of Talmud Torah teaches that there is no continuity without content, and that the survival of the Jewish people, while dependent upon the marshalling of military and political force where necessary, cannot be sustained through these efforts alone. In a world where all Jews are Jews by choice we will be sustained only to the extent that we field a product worthy of perpetuation, and a religion filled with ideas and values that inspire commitment and give meaning to belonging.
As we celebrate Shavuot, we need more than a Tikkun Leil Shavuot. We need a Tikkun for our people. We need to recommit to being a people of great ideas. It was these ideas that constituted the revolution that was and is Judaism and which inspired us over the centuries. We need to keep continuing to inspire ourselves if we are to do justice to our heritage and create the foundations for our future.

You care about Israel, peoplehood, and vibrant, ethical Jewish communities. We do too.

Join our email list for more Hartman ideas

More on
Join our email list


The End of Policy Substance in Israel Politics