/ articles for review

Shas, Reform Jews and our Inheritance

In response to the critique of Reform Jews, Steve Moskowitz says no one can be written out of the Jewish people. Our tradition is the inheritance of all
Rabbi Moskowitz is at the rabbi of Congregation L’Dor V’Dor in Oyster Bay, NY. He received his rabbinic ordination from the Hebrew Union College-Jewish Institute of Religion. He is a devoted Jewish teacher, sharing with us his love of the Bible and Jewish philosophy.  He has taught in the internationally acclaimed Florence Melton Adult Mini School, UJA Connections, and the Institute for Adult Jewish Studies.  Rabbi Moskowitz is deeply committed to Israel and travels there every

Originally posted on Times of Israel


This week Israel’s Religious Affairs Minister David Azoulay, from the ultra-Orthodox Shas party, suggested that Reform Jews should not be considered Jewish. He said, “Let’s just say there’s a problem as soon as a Reform Jew stops following the religion of Israel. I can’t allow myself to say that such a person is a Jew.”

This week we read about Zelophehad’s daughters. They approach Moses demanding that the law of inheritance be revised so that their father’s memory will endure. They say, “Our father died in the wilderness…. Let not our father’s name be lost to his clan just because he had no son! Give us a holding among our father’s kinsmen!” (Numbers 27) Justice demands the law be changed.

  • Read another perspective on this subject from Rabbis Ken Chasen and Yoshi Zweiback, who like Steven Moskowitz, are Senior Rabbinic Fellows of the Shalom Hartman Institute

Right wing parties often criticize Reform, accusing it of picking and choosing from the tradition. Authentic, “Torah true Judaism,” is not piecemeal but instead the entire package, they argue. This view fails to understand the human heart. Moreover this philosophy fails to recognize the historical truth that everyone picks and chooses. Do you for example emphasize Zelophehad’s daughters or Pinchas, who kills the Israelite idolaters? Both stories are found in this week’s Torah portion. The sermon begins with one verse. The choices made are different in every synagogue, whether Reform or ultra-Orthodox, Israeli or American.

In addition ultra-Orthodox rabbis imagine that they, and they alone, are faithful to the past, and that their beliefs and practices remain unchanging. This mythologizes Jewish history. Judaism has always changed. It has survived not because it has remained fixed but instead because it has adapted to different historical circumstances. In fact ultra-Orthodoxy is a response to modernity. It is but one answer to the pressures of contemporary society. In essence ultra-Orthodox leaders state that all modern values must be shut out and that Judaism, and Jews, can learn nothing from modernity.

I believe however that it is impossible to close our eyes to modernity and that there is much to learn from contemporary society.

We must renew our tradition and even have the courage to reimagine our inheritance. My Judaism is far different than that of my grandparents. Likewise my grandchildren’s will be unimaginably different from my own. This is not only because I don’t yet have grandchildren but also because I cannot envision the future, the values it might teach and the accommodations Judaism might need to make to it.

Reform Judaism is an open door; it offers a welcome to our sacred texts. It is an invitation to reread these words with new, contemporary eyes.

I believe Judaism is about change. We must bend toward contemporary times and accommodate modernity. We must adapt to modern values. Today’s Judaism demands a marriage of tradition with modernity.

Here in Jerusalem, at the Shalom Hartman Institute, we study traditional sources in an effort to fashion a new and vibrant modern Jewish life. There are nearly 200 rabbis studying here. Here Jewish pluralism is modeled and learned. I do not imagine that any one us reads these texts with the same eyes. I do not imagine that any one of us has the same answer or response to modernity. Nonetheless I love listening to our discussions and debates. I open the doors of the Institute to discover the sounds of colleagues and friends arguing over the words of our sacred tradition.

It is not the answers that I most value but the music of those discussions. It is in those notes that I know the future will be sustained.

We rewrite our sacred texts. We reread the words of our inheritance.

I have faith in learning Torah.

The study of Torah will be found in each and every generation.

There are millions of Jews in the United States and Israel who like myself wish to live lives that are both modern and Jewish. We can only do so with our eyes open wide to modernity. We can only do so with the pages of our Torah unveiled before us.

Our sacred texts are open to reinterpretation. Our Judaism is forever changing. And that is why our people will endure.

No one can be written out of the Jewish people. Our tradition is the inheritance of all.

“And the Lord said to Moses, “The plea of Zelophehad’s daughters is just…”

Rabbi Steven Moskowitz is the rabbi of the Jewish Congregation of Brookville and the Oyster Bay Jewish Center and a Senior Rabbinic Fellow of the Shalom Hartman Institute,

You care about Israel, peoplehood, and vibrant, ethical Jewish communities. We do too.

Join our email list for more Hartman ideas

Add a comment
Join our email list


The End of Policy Substance in Israel Politics