Join our email list

Pinchas: Regarding Leadership and Spirit

It is Moshe’s experience of God here that inspires him to turn to God as the God of spirits&quot
Photo: James Tissot/Wikimedia Commons
Photo: James Tissot/Wikimedia Commons
Rabbi Avital Hochstein is a faculty member at the Shalom Hartman Institute and has learned, taught, and done research at the institute for more than 15 years. In 2016, she was among the first recipients of rabbinical ordination from the Shalom Hartman Institute / HaMidrasha at Oranim Beit Midrash for Israeli Rabbis. Avital is currently working on her Ph.D., focusing on Talmud, in the Gender Studies Program at Bar Ilan University. Avital is President of

Pinchas: Regarding Leadership and Spirit

What are the required qualities of a leader? What makes a good leader? How is a retiring leader supposed to designate a successor? Our parashah suggests surprising and complex answers to these questions.

One of the most dramatic moments in this week’s Torah reading is when God informs Moshe how he will die, and reminds him why he will not be allowed to continue to lead the people as they enter into the land of Israel:

BeMidbar 27:12-14

12″Ascend these heights of Abarim and view the land that I have given to the Israelite people. 13 When you have seen it, you too shall be gathered to your kin, just as your brother Aaron was. 14 For, in the wilderness of Zin, when the community was contentious, you disobeyed My command to uphold My sanctity in their sight by means of the water.” Those are the Waters of Meribath-kadesh, in the wilderness of Zin.

Later on, in the book of Devarim, Moshe begs for clemency. But here, in our parashah, Moshe seems to resign himself to his fate and turns his focus to the future. Moshe requests that God appoint a replacement for him: “Let YHVH, God of the spirits of all flesh, appoint (yifkod) someone over the community” (BeMidbar 27:16).

Every word in this request is fascinating and loaded; we will here address just a few points.

The word “appointment” (yifkod) here comes from the root pkd. Indeed, it is common in the Bible for this verb to be used when people are assigned to positions of authority. For example, the Torah describes how Yoseph was assigned a position of authority by Potiphar:

Bereishit 39:4

He took a liking to Yoseph. He made him his personal attendant and appointed him (vayafvideihu) to be in charge of his household, placing in his hands all that he owned.

However, the root pkd can also invoke the sense of Divine presence and intervention. In the very next verse of the Yoseph story, we hear how this appointment affected Yoseph and Potiphar’s household:

Bereishit 39:5

And from the time that the Egyptian appointed him to be in charge of his household and of all that he owned, the Lord blessed his house for Yoseph’s sake, so that the blessing of the Lord was upon everything that he owned, in the house and outside.

Even more directly, the root pkd is used by Yoseph himself when he tells his brothers about a future redemption to take place at God’s hands:

Bereishit 50:4

At length, Yoseph said to his brothers, “I am about to die. God will surely take notice (pakod yifkod) of you and bring you up from this land to the land that He promised on oath to Abraham, to Isaac, and to Jacob.”

In light of this linguistic connection, we can suggest that Moshe’s request is not merely that God appoint a functional successor, but rather that this appointment carry with it Divine presence and involvement – both for the leader and the people – as was the case in Moshe’s life. Indeed, God goes above and beyond the call in responding to Moshe’s request by choosing a man whose qualities are identical to Moshe’s understanding of God’s own qualities:

BeMidbar 27:15-18

Moshe spoke to God, saying, “Let YHVH, God of the spirits of all flesh, appoint (yifkod) someone over the community…And YHVH answered Moshe, “Single out Yehoshua son of Nun, a man imbued with spirit, and lay your hand upon him…”

The God of spirits appoints a man imbued with spirit.

In early midrashim from the period of the Mishnah, we find two dueling narratives that base themselves on the expression “God of spirits” used here to describe God. In Sifrei BeMidbar, God is described as One who is responsible for all spirits – a ruler and master over the lives of all people: “Let YHVH, God of the spirits of all flesh – Here Scripture clarifies that there is no spirit that does not emerge from God” (Sifrei BeMidbar Pinhas #139).

The Sifrei’s description proceeds to connect the phrase “God of spirits” to the root pkd: “R. Eliezer the son of R. Yose Hagelili says: As long as a person is alive, his souls is entrusted (pekudah) to his maker, as it says…’I will entrust my spirit in His hand.” In this description, God is the “God of spirits” in account of being responsible for the spirits of human beings who entrust their spirits to God.

But the explanation of a parallel midrash in Sifrei Zuta reveals a different perspective. There, the God of spirits is described as a God who can contain a variety of spirits, a diverse range of people. The emphasis here is not on God’s authority but God’s capacity:

“Let YHVH, God of the spirits of all flesh – The God who knows the thoughts and spirit of each and every person, who is tall and who is short, who is measured and who exacting. [And so it says: “The One who fashioned their hearts together and understands all of their ways” (Psalms 33:15). And so it says: “God probes hearts” (Proverbs 21:2).]

Different midrashim then also connect God’s nature as a “God of spirits” to the selection of

Yehoshua (1)

Sifrei Zuta, as we saw, describes God as one who understands what is distinctive about each and every human being. This text goes on to connect this divine quality with Moshe’s request:

“God said to Moshe: Take Yehoshua” – Since Moshe said: “Let YHVH, God of the spirits of all flesh,” the Omnipresent said to Moshe: Your request has been granted…”A man imbued with spirit” – he will know how to engage those who are exacting as well as those who are measured.”

This is a fascinating midrash, for a few reasons. First, as we noted, it aligns Moshe description of God as “God of spirits” with God’s description of Joshua as “a man imbued with spirit.” Second, it suggests that Yehoshua himself was a man who could embrace diverse people and engage with them. Third, the midrash suggests that God understood from Moshe’s mere description of the Divine, that Moshe was seeking a replacement imbued with the very qualities captured by that description. Rashi clarifies and sharpens all of this for us:

Rashi on BeMidbar 27:16

“God of spirits” – What is the point of this phrase? Moshe said to God: Master of the Universe! Everyone’s unique and diverse thoughts are revealed and known to you-Appoint a leader for them who will be able to bear each and every one of them.

And so, Moshe’s request and hope is for a leader who will be able to embrace the multivocality of the community and the diverse and varied individuals who comprise it.

I will end with a note from an adjacent section of our parashah, and a suggestion that these two are connected. Right before Moshe requests a successor, we hear about the request of the daughters of Tzelofhad: “Give us an inheritance among our father’s brothers” (BeMidbar 27:4). Moshe does not give them an immediate and direct answer, rather he refers the matter to God: “Moshe brought their claim to God.” The divine response is unambiguous: “God said to Moshe as follows: Indeed, the daughters of Tzelofhad speak justly” (BeMidbar 27:5,7).

God here is able to embrace the statements and claims of the daughters of Tzelofhad, to proclaim them as just, even when their words push beyond mainstream thinking of the day. I would like to suggest that it is Moshe’s experience of God here that inspires him to turn to God as the “God of spirits,” the God who is capable of hearing many different voices and of bringing them into the divine realms of truth and justice. Perhaps this is how we should understand Moshe’s request for a “man imbued with spirit” – someone who understands the spirits of different people.

Perhaps Moshe understands and has internalized his own shortcomings. He was not able (on his own) to fully embrace all of the “spirits” and to accept the words of the daughters of Tzelofhad. He therefore hopes for a new leader who will succeed him and who can attain these divine heights.



[1] Rabbeinu Bahya, in his commentary on BeMidbar 27:16, sees Moshe’s understanding of God’s nature described here as directly related to his request. According to R. Bahya, Moshe asks God to use the Divine insights about human beings in order to arrive at an appropriate choice: “Let YHVH, God of the spirits of all flesh” – You who know the spirit of each and every person and which of them is worthy to be their leader.

You care about Israel, peoplehood, and vibrant, ethical Jewish communities. We do too.

Join our email list for more Hartman ideas

Join our email list


The End of Policy Substance in Israel Politics